---
title: EDDM vs a Targeted Mailing List: How to Choose
url: https://carmichaelprinting.com/guides/eddm-vs-mailing-lists/
business: Carmichael Printing Company, Inc.
what: commercial printing, copying, graphic design and prepress, binding and finishing, mailing and fulfillment
phone: (916) 487-8679
email: service@carmichaelprinting.com
address: 5757 Robertson Avenue, Suite B, Carmichael, CA 95608 (one block off Fair Oaks Blvd)
hours: Mon-Fri 9:00 am - 4:30 pm, Sat-Sun closed
since: 1965
quotes: most within one business day
---

- [Home](https://carmichaelprinting.com/)
- [Guides](https://carmichaelprinting.com/guides/)
- EDDM vs a targeted mailing list

5 min read - updated November 2026

# EDDM vs a targeted mailing list

EDDM reaches every address on the carrier routes you choose with a generic "Postal Customer" piece, while a mailing list reaches specific named people you pick. Choose EDDM to cover a neighborhood and a list to speak to customers, members or donors by name.

Key points

- EDDM is by route and address; a list is by name
- A list allows personal greetings and merged details
- EDDM suits openings, sales and neighborhood notices
- Lists suit renewals, appeals and past-customer offers
- You can use both for different goals

Both are direct mail, and both start at the print shop, but they solve different problems. Think about who you want to reach, how much you know about them and whether a name on the envelope will help. Carmichael Printing prints both kinds of piece and handles mailing lists and mail merges.

## The core difference

With EDDM, the USPS delivers your piece to every address on the routes you select, and the address line reads "Postal Customer." You choose where, not who. With a mailing list, each piece goes to a person or household whose name and address are on your list.

Direct mail experts describe the second approach as targeted mail, where senders choose recipients most likely to respond, and the first as mail sent neighborhood by neighborhood.

## Side by side

Use this table as a quick filter.

Side by side Question EDDM Retail Targeted list

Who gets it Every address on chosen routes Named people you select

Address line Postal Customer Name and street address

Personal greeting No Yes, through a mail merge

Minimum 200 pieces Set by your list and job

Best for Awareness in a neighborhood Customers, members, donors

## When EDDM is the better fit

Choose EDDM when your customer is anyone nearby: a new restaurant, a home-service business, a school fundraiser, a neighborhood open house. You do not need a list and you can pick routes with the USPS online tool, which shows Census-based household figures. See [how EDDM works](https://carmichaelprinting.com/guides/how-eddm-works/).

## When a list is the better fit

A list lets you write to the people who already know you. A church can mail its members, a nonprofit its donors, a business its past customers. Because each piece has a name, you can merge that name into the greeting and add details such as an account number or an event table. See [what is a mail merge](https://carmichaelprinting.com/guides/what-is-a-mail-merge/) and [mailing lists](https://carmichaelprinting.com/services/mailing-lists/).

A list is only as good as its addresses, so clean it first. See [mailing list cleanup basics](https://carmichaelprinting.com/guides/mailing-list-hygiene/).

## Using both

Many senders run a list mailing to customers and an EDDM piece to the surrounding streets with the same design. Print them together to keep the look consistent. Carmichael Printing can create, print and mail a newsletter, even to 40,000 homes, and can talk through the options for your mailing.

## Questions to ask before you choose

Do you know the people you want to reach? If yes, a list fits. If your customer is anyone in a ZIP Code, EDDM fits. Will the message change for different people? A list lets you vary it. Is the goal awareness or a response from a particular group?

Think about follow-up too. A list you build becomes an asset that you can use again and add to, while an EDDM route is something you choose each time.

- Goal: awareness or a reply from known people
- Audience: a whole neighborhood or a defined group
- Message: the same for everyone or personal
- Timing: a one-time event or a recurring mailing

## How the printing differs

The printed piece itself can be the same size and paper for both. What changes is the address side. An EDDM piece needs space for the indicia and the "Postal Customer" line. A list piece needs room for a name, a street line, and often a return address, plus the space the post office wants around the address.

If you plan to merge names onto the piece, leave an open panel in your design and tell us which side it is on. We set the name and address into that panel from your list. A fixed design with an empty panel is easier to mail than one where the address has to squeeze around the artwork.

### Sources (2)

- U.S. Postal Service : [usps.com/business/every-door-direct-mail.htm](https://www.usps.com/business/every-door-direct-mail.htm) (checked November 2026)
- Wikipedia : [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Direct_mail](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Direct_mail) (checked November 2026)

## Ready when you are

Send the file, a sample to match, or just the details. Most quotes within one business day.

[Get a quote](#quote)[Send a file](https://carmichaelprinting.com/send-a-file/)

## Keep reading

- [How USPS Every Door Direct Mail works](https://carmichaelprinting.com/guides/how-eddm-works/)
- [What is a mail merge?](https://carmichaelprinting.com/guides/what-is-a-mail-merge/)
- [Mailing list cleanup basics](https://carmichaelprinting.com/guides/mailing-list-hygiene/)
- [Mailing lists](https://carmichaelprinting.com/services/mailing-lists/)
- [Mailing & fulfillment](https://carmichaelprinting.com/services/mailing-and-fulfillment/)

Questions

## Questions we hear

[All questions](https://carmichaelprinting.com/faq/)

### Is EDDM cheaper than a list mailing?

Rates vary and USPS sets postage, so we do not quote them here. Check usps.com for the current EDDM price and ask us for a quote on the printing.

### Can I use EDDM with a name on it?

EDDM Retail pieces are addressed to "Postal Customer." If you want names, you need a list and a different mailing.

### Do you help with mailing lists?

Yes. Ask us about your mailing and tell us what you want to achieve.
