---
title: Proofs and Approvals: What to Check Before You Sign
url: https://carmichaelprinting.com/guides/proofs-and-approvals/
business: Carmichael Printing Company, Inc.
what: commercial printing, copying, graphic design and prepress, binding and finishing, mailing and fulfillment
phone: (916) 487-8679
email: service@carmichaelprinting.com
address: 5757 Robertson Avenue, Suite B, Carmichael, CA 95608 (one block off Fair Oaks Blvd)
hours: Mon-Fri 9:00 am - 4:30 pm, Sat-Sun closed
since: 1965
quotes: most within one business day
---

- [Home](https://carmichaelprinting.com/)
- [Guides](https://carmichaelprinting.com/guides/)
- Proofs and approvals: what to check

5 min read - updated November 2026

# Proofs and approvals: what to check

A proof is the final type and artwork shown to you before printing, and your signed approval is what lets the job go to press. Check every word, number, date, image position and color on the proof, because proofreading is the customer's responsibility.

Shown: checking a proof against color swatches (stock photo)

Key points

- The proof is sent by email or shown in person
- A cover sheet comes with every proof
- Work proceeds on a signed approval
- We correct our copy errors at no charge
- Customer revisions and edits are charged

The proof is the least costly place to find a mistake. After the press runs, the same mistake means a reprint. A calm ten minutes with the proof, and a second pair of eyes, is the best protection for your job.

## What a proof is for

Wikipedia describes proofing as a verification step before the final press run that serves as an agreement between customer and printer. Catching errors at this stage is far cheaper than correcting them on press. For us, a proof means the final rendering of type and artwork, sent by email or shown in person, with a cover sheet attached.

## A proofing checklist

- Read every word aloud, slowly, from the first line to the last.
- Check names, titles, phone numbers, email and web addresses digit by digit.
- Check dates, days of the week and times against a calendar.
- Look at the positioning of logos, photos and borders.
- Check the quantity, size and paper against your order.
- Have a second person read it, ideally someone new to the content.
- Sign and return the approval, or mark your changes clearly.

## Who pays for corrections?

We correct our own copy errors at no charge. Customer revisions and edits are charged, and a new proof follows, so gather every change into one round when you can. Because proofreading is the customer's responsibility, a typo that was in your file and passed your approval is on the approved copy. That is the reason to slow down at this step.

## What the proof does not show

A proof on a screen or an office printer shows layout and content, but it cannot show the exact shade of every ink, the feel of the paper, or a raised thermography finish. If color or paper feel matters to you, say so when you get the quote and ask us about paper choices. See [why colors shift in print](https://carmichaelprinting.com/guides/cmyk-vs-rgb/) for what to expect.

## Return it promptly

Send the signed proof back as soon as you have checked it, so the project is not delayed. If your deadline is tight, say so when you send the file, and we will tell you honestly what is possible. See [how to plan a print timeline](https://carmichaelprinting.com/guides/plan-your-print-timeline/) for ways to leave room for a second proof.

## Common errors a proof catches

Because the proof is your agreement on what will print, take the time to look at each of these. A trick that works well is to read the proof backward, one line at a time from the bottom, which breaks the habit of reading what you expect to see.

- A transposed digit in a phone number or ZIP code
- An old date or hours of operation that was never updated
- A name or title spelled differently from last year's piece
- A logo that is stretched, or the wrong version
- A picture that moved when a font changed
- A missing line of text at the end of a page

## Changes after the first proof

If you mark changes, a new proof follows, and you check it again from the top. Do not assume a correction was made; look for it. Keep a list of the changes you asked for, tick each one off on the new proof, and sign only when every item is done. That small habit prevents the most common repeat mistake.

### Sources (2)

- Wikipedia : [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prepress_proofing](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prepress_proofing) (checked November 2026)
- Wikipedia : [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prepress](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prepress) (checked November 2026)

## Ready when you are

Send the file, a sample to match, or just the details. Most quotes within one business day.

[Get a quote](#quote)[Send a file](https://carmichaelprinting.com/send-a-file/)

## Keep reading

- [How does proofing and approval work?](https://carmichaelprinting.com/faq/proofing-and-approval/)
- [How a print job works](https://carmichaelprinting.com/how-a-job-works/)
- [How to plan a print job timeline](https://carmichaelprinting.com/guides/plan-your-print-timeline/)
- [Print-ready file checklist](https://carmichaelprinting.com/guides/file-prep-checklist-for-print/)

Questions

## Questions we hear

[All questions](https://carmichaelprinting.com/faq/)

### Do I have to sign the proof?

Yes. Work proceeds when we have a signature and approval on your proof sheet.

### What if I find an error after approving?

Call us right away. Work proceeds on your signed approval and proofreading is the customer's responsibility, so check carefully before signing.

### Do you check my spelling?

We look for print problems in the file, not spelling or grammar, so please proofread everything.
